I cannot bring myself to rate this higher than a 7. Probably because I read the book at 17yo and that it forever moved me. I had no clue a movie existed from the book. But I just had to watch it—it forever changed me.
It made me realise that I myself suffered from PTSD that was deeply repressed, from a similar event, and it brought me to seek help. The way my body felt while reading the book, I can still feel it sometimes when I think about it.
Kristen Stewart was THE perfect cast for Melinda. I think she portrayed the character as perfect as possible, and she made a strong impression.
I believe it is not as good as the book, because the book is one true piece of art, but it is still worth it, as it shows how one copes when they cannot speak about something that won’t come out.
Cet utilisateur l'a également ajouté à sa liste Favs
Créée
le 7 janv. 2024
Critique lue 7 fois
D'autres avis sur Speak
Speak à 11 ans. En France il pourrait très bien ressortir aujourd'hui. Portant un sujet que l'on trouve beaucoup depuis quelques années comme si celui-là était nouveau : le harcèlement scolaire...
Par
le 20 juin 2015
7 j'aime
Speak est un très bon film réalisé par Jessica Sharzer basé sur la nouvelle homonyme écrite par Laurie Halse Anderson qui met en scéne la très jeune Kristen Stewart (excellente tout en présence) qui...
Par
le 1 avr. 2015
5 j'aime
Un film touchant qui parle de sujet actuel et sensible. On ne comprend pas tout de suite Melinda, on croit que elle est replié sur elle-meme à cause du rejet de ses amis. Et la on voit tout, sa...
Par
le 2 mai 2013
4 j'aime
Du même critique
The Perks of being a Wallflower is one of the first movies I remember watching after going through a hard time. I was in high school at the time. Safe to say I found refuge in it (and the book—which...
Par
le 7 janv. 2024
First, we must all agree that Fincher was so clever for putting this movie together. Truly.Let’s talk casting—perfection. Never seen Pitt in any movie that resembles Fight Club, and Norton, well, he...
Par
le 7 janv. 2024
If you like psychological thrillers, I think this is an easy watch.Oliver’s character carried the movie—both as a character but as an interesting personality.It goes deep into studying various mental...
Par
le 7 janv. 2024
