As the Moon, So Beautiful
7.1
As the Moon, So Beautiful

Anime (mangas) Tokyo MX (2017)

Vu en simulcast (sur ?).


Good to see something going against its period's trends. As for the rest...
It was pretty exhausting at times, notably thanks to the proeminence of LINE text messaging to express various dialogues (you should never center episodes around instant messaging). On the other hand, the use of it to present various later life moments in the ending was a good choice (though it wasn't used to depict anything interesting in itself).
The whole series seemed to aim for a certain realism by portraying middleschoolers scheming, being jealous, stupid and senseless etc like we expect while having in mind a conclusion making the heroes look like extraordinary people.
After a while, I felt like this was something good for 10year olds (the ones who would still be able to believe in those school crushes lasting forever) but made for young adults (night anime).
The final outcome came out of nowhere for a supposedly down-to-earth romance, despite being clearly planned. Also, after discussing their future at several occasions, we have no idea how it turned out for both of them (unless a wedding and a baby were their only good perspectives).


Technically, there were many drawings problems (things (dis)appearing, faces, etc) but I liked the characters drawing style. Though this white outline for light made the insertion on full CGI backgrounds* even uglier than in Witch Hunter Robin. That's sad because both the characters and backgrounds are fine on their own. Some scenes focusing on their feelings, notably crying ones, looked quite good compared to what I'm used to.


Score: 5~7/10. Totally forgettable as soon as you stop considering its time frame.


Enjoyment: 2/5


Mention spéciale aux scénettes clôturant chaque épisode.

AyanamiRei
5
Écrit par

Créée

le 21 oct. 2020

Critique lue 106 fois

Rei Ayanami

Écrit par

Critique lue 106 fois

D'autres avis sur As the Moon, So Beautiful

As the Moon, So Beautiful

As the Moon, So Beautiful

8

BlackLight

48 critiques

Pourquoi adorer détester Tsuki Ga Kirei

Tsuki ga Kirei est un anime de romance somme toute assez classique, parmi ceux qui nous transportent dans une fable contemporaine en nous enlaçant dans leur chaleur mielleuse. Si la plupart de ces...

le 28 sept. 2017

As the Moon, So Beautiful

As the Moon, So Beautiful

8

Mottainai

43 critiques

En orbite et au-delà

Diantre, me voilà pris la main dans le sac. Ce sac que j’ai cru ne plus jamais revoir est réapparu. Tout en étant allongé en position latérale sur mon lit, l’inattendu s’est produit. J’ai retrouvé...

le 5 avr. 2019

As the Moon, So Beautiful

As the Moon, So Beautiful

9

Heyden17

30 critiques

La force d'un premier amour

Cela faisait longtemps que je n’avais pas pleuré devant un anime. Plus sérieusement, Tsuki ga Kirei est l’excellente surprise de ce printemps 2017. Je ne pensais pas que j’apprécierais autant cet...

le 25 févr. 2018

Du même critique

Joker

Joker

5

AyanamiRei

1840 critiques

Pas une critique!

Vu en salle. "un film d’auteur maquillé sous les traits d’un projet grand public." J'ai vu l'inverse: un réalisateur tentant de singer, dans l'apparence, un "film d'auteur". J'ai eu l'impression...

le 2 janv. 2020

Icare

Icare

6

AyanamiRei

1840 critiques

Pas une critique!

Vu en avant-première, ateliers Premiers Plans 2022. The Minotaur legend twisted into a hollow kiddie fate & friendship tale wich the myth serves simply as a backdrop for. While trying to flesh...

le 29 janv. 2022

Helen Mirren, une actrice royale

Helen Mirren, une actrice royale

5

AyanamiRei

1840 critiques

Pas une critique !

Vu sur ARTE, soirée (et cycle) Helen Mirren. Un rapide survol de la longue carrière de l'actrice britannique s'intéressant notamment à ses débuts, peu connus en France, et dévoilant son...

le 30 août 2023